CrowdCurated
Working With Buyers·PRO TIP GOLD

How to Compare Two Lenders When Both of Them Quoted the Same Rate

Your client is comparing two lenders on the rate, because the rate is the number both of them lead with. One box on the loan estimate holds everything the lender is actually charging, and a rate that looks too good to be true usually has that box paying for it.

From Jeb Smith, "Refinance NOW Or REGRET It Later"· August 17, 2025Open the source ↗
The Quick Take

The video is about whether to refinance, and the useful half is a list of things to watch on the paperwork.

First, the box. "anything that's on box A on your loan estimate is essentially points that you're paying for that mortgage." It might be labeled origination points, a processing fee or an admin fee. His comparison method is one line: look at box A on one loan estimate against box A on the other and see what is being charged.

Second, no out-of-pocket cost is not the same as no cost. A lender saying there are no out-of-pocket charges may be rolling the fees into the balance, so a client who owed $500,000 now owes $510,000 and usually does not know why the loan grew.

Third, the term reset. Watch for a lender who puts the client back into a fresh thirty-year term on every refinance, because that inflates the monthly saving without saving anything. His fix: "have your lender give you a quote based on the current term of your mortgage."

Fourth, the rule of thumb he uses to decide whether the call is even worth making — what he calls the $125,000 formula, which he says his lender has used with clients for years. Divide $125,000 by the loan amount and you get the rate improvement you need: on a $125,000 loan, 1%; on $250,000, half a percent; on $500,000, a quarter; on a million, about an eighth. He is explicit that it only tells you whether to have the conversation.

Fifth, the break-even, which is what the formula does not capture. Loan costs divided by monthly savings gives you the months to recoup. Save $100 a month at a $5,000 cost and that is 50 months, just over four years — and if the client is selling inside four years it does not pay.

He also describes doing a no-cost refinance himself last September, by his own account: he took a rate slightly above the day's best, the lender credit covered the closing costs, he kept the same loan term, and he saved almost $500 a month.

The Useful Part

“anything that's on box A on your loan estimate is essentially points that you're paying for that mortgage”

Our Take

You are not the lender and you should not be quoting rates, but you are usually the first person a client shows two loan estimates to. Knowing that one box holds the lender's own charges lets you ask the only question that matters — why is box A different — without pretending to underwrite anything.

The term reset is the one that costs clients most and gets noticed least, because it disguises itself as savings. A borrower two years into a thirty-year note who refinances into a new thirty-year note has bought a lower payment with twenty-four extra months of interest, and the comparison sheet will call that a win. Asking for the quote at the remaining term makes the two loans comparable, and it takes one sentence.

Do This
  1. When a client sends you two loan estimates, put them side by side and compare box A against box A before you look at the rate.
  2. Ask each lender to quote at the client's current remaining term rather than a fresh thirty years, so the savings figure is real.
  3. Have the client divide total loan costs by the monthly saving to get the break-even in months, and check it against how long they plan to keep the house.
More Like This